Children’s voices for change
Children’s voices for change: A rights-based approach to understanding and implementing effective supports for children and pre-adolescents as victim-survivors of family violence
The Children’s Voices for Change project engaged children and young people as family violence experts by experience – as research participants, co-researchers and Youth Advisory Group members – to enhance our collective understanding of the diversity and distinctiveness of children’s experiences of family violence, and the effectiveness of services in meeting their needs. The project reviewed the existing Victorian family violence service landscape and analysed aggregated client data from The Orange Door, to understand children’s system pathways; it surveyed 320 practitioners who provide support services to children who have experienced family violence; conducted participatory research with 23 children and young people who have accessed family violence support services in Victoria; and co-created a Children’s Feedback Tool through collaborative workshops with children and young people and practitioners.
Children's Voice for Change: Project launch event recording
Aims
The key aims of the project are to:
- Understand how children and pre-adolescents conceive their family violence response and recovery needs;
- Identify supportive factors that facilitate meaningful engagement with children and pre-adolescents in a way that meets their needs and respects their evolving capacities;
- Identify conceptual and practical barriers to the development and operation of effective family violence support services for children and pre-adolescents as victim-survivors in their own right; and
- Develop clear, practical capacity-building resources to enable children’s meaningful, safe participation in family violence program design and service delivery, including measuring and monitoring the effectiveness of outcomes.
This project will contribute to the growing knowledge and evidence base about the needs of children and pre-adolescents who have experienced family violence, and how best to respond. It will highlight the gaps between what children and pre-adolescents identify as important in their family violence response and recovery needs, and what is happening in practice.
Significance
Research evidence and sector insights highlight gaps in:
- Understanding the distinct and unique needs of children and pre-adolescents as victim-survivors of family violence in their own right;
- Which service responses are most effective in meeting the needs of children and pre-adolescents;
- How to meaningfully engage with this group and centralise their voices, views and experiences; and
- How to embed rights-based, child-centred and trauma-informed processes into practice and build evidence about their effectiveness.
Methods
The project is proceeding in four phases:
Phase 1: Literature Review and Data Analysis
A review of the existing Victorian family violence service landscape, including analysis of aggregated client data from The Orange Door, to understand children and pre-adolescent system pathways. This phase will also produce a literature review of the evidence base in Victoria and other jurisdictions for meeting the needs of children and pre-adolescents as victim-survivors of family violence in their own right.
Phase 2: Practitioner Survey
A survey of practitioners who provide support services to children and pre adolescents who have experienced family violence, to identify supportive factors and barriers to effectiveness in this context.
Phase 3: Participatory research with children and young people
An interactive online activity, to give children and young people who are victim-survivors of family violence the opportunity to safely and meaningfully share their views about, and experiences of, engagement with support services, and to tell us what they need to feel safe and well.
Phase 4: Co-design of Children's Feedback Tool
Co-design workshops with practitioners and children and young people to develop and test a Children’s Feedback Tool for use by government and community sector organisations, to inform their practice development and ongoing workforce capacity building priorities. The Tool will enable services that support children and pre-adolescent victim-survivors of family violence to centre children’s experiences and to measure effectiveness through the lens of those experiences. It will also support iterative and ongoing workforce capacity building and measurement regarding both what is needed to support effective outcomes for children and pre-adolescents, and how to work with this group in a child-centred, trauma-informed way that promotes and upholds their rights.
The project’s six key findings:
1. There is no ‘one size fits all’ for supporting children and young people who have experienced family violence.
Children who experience intersecting forms of structural oppression and marginalisation face greater barriers to accessing family violence supports and having their needs met.
2. Children need connection, trust and loving relationships with family, friends and pets, to enable them to heal from family violence.
They also want to ensure that they and their family members are safe, healthy and well, and that they have financial security and housing stability.
3. Building and maintaining trust with the child is very important.
Children and young people described services breaching their trust by disclosing information to others, by not understanding their experiences of family violence, and by Victoria Police actions, including where police had seemingly ‘sided’ with the person using violence; children and young people were perceived to be lying about their experiences of family violence; police had failed to respond adequately to their situation; and police actions undermined their safety.
4. Asking children for feedback about their service experience about their service experience is not common practice in Victoria.
Less than half of practitioners (144/315 = 46%) said their service seeks feedback from children. Where children do give feedback, it is usually through an adult.
5. There are still many barriers to supporting children as victim-survivors of family violence in their own right:
- The specialist family violence service system is insufficiently resourced: practitioners and children alike emphasised their concerns about long wait times to access services, staff shortages and high staff turnover, a lack of specialised programs and therapeutic interventions, insufficient case management periods, and a lack of practitioner expertise and confidence.
- Family law parenting orders often make it hard for services to help children or put children at risk of harm.
- The need for parental consent to engage with services can be used by the person using violence to prevent children’s access to support, as a form of control and ongoing abuse;
- Financial support and housing stability are key unmet needs for children who have experienced family violence.
- Services do not always collaborate and communicate effectively to ensure that important risk information about children is appropriately shared and acted upon.
6. Services and systems must listen to, hear and understand children.
We need to seek children’s direct, unfiltered voices about their family violence response and recovery needs to be able to meet those needs effectively.
Project reports are available here.
CHANGE Children’s Feedback Tool.
Project Team
The project is led by Dr Georgina Dimopoulos of Southern Cross University, in collaboration with researchers at Swinburne University of Technology and project partners Safe and Equal and the Centre for Excellence in Child and Family Welfare.
Southern Cross University
Dr Georgina Dimopoulos – Lead Chief Investigator
Harrison Cant – Research Assistant
Holly Aitken – Research Assistant
Eliza Hew – Research Assistant
Swinburne University of Technology
Dr Mitchell Adams – Co-Investigator
Safe and Equal
Louise Simms – Co-Investigator
Ella Longhurst – Project Officer
Centre for Excellence in Child and Family Welfare
Dr Michele Lonsdale – Co-Investigator
Dr Mandy Charman – Co-Investigator
The team is supported by a Project Advisory Group and a Youth Advisory Group.
Funding
The project is funded by Family Safety Victoria, through Phase 1 of its Family Violence Research Grants Program.
Outputs and Presentations
Centre for Excellence in Child and Family Welfare webinar, AVITH in Context: Young Person Intimate Partner Violence (IPV) (online, 8 May 2023)
Outcomes, Practice and Evidence Network (OPEN) Research Symposium, Children’s Voices for Change: Learning from Children and Young People as Experts by Experience to Improve Family Violence Services (Centre for Excellence in Child and Family Welfare, online, 25 October 2023)
Children, Trauma and the Law Conference, Learning from Children as Experts by Experience to Inform Research, Policy and Practice (Southern Cross University, Lismore, 11-12 October 2023)
Elevating Children’s Voices in Family Violence Services Forum, Children’s Voices for Change: A Rights-Based Approach to Supporting Children Victim-Survivors (Kids First Australia, Melbourne, 10 October 2023)
Family & Relationship Services Australia National Conference, Children’s Voices for Change: Co-designing and Evaluating Family Violence Support Services (Gold Coast, 16 May 2023)
Project Contact
Dr Georgina Dimopoulos: georgina.dimopoulos@scu.edu.au